Questions to Ask Before Buying a Used Watch Online
The listing looked clean. A Seiko SARB033, stainless steel, black dial, "excellent condition, keeps great time", with eight bright photos and a price about 15 percent below what that model usually fetched.

The listing looked clean. A Seiko SARB033, stainless steel, black dial, "excellent condition, keeps great time", with eight bright photos and a price about 15 percent below what that model usually fetched. A reader sent it to me in January and asked whether it was a good buy. I could not tell him, and neither could he, because the listing answered none of the questions that decide what a used watch is actually worth.
Most people buying a pre-owned watch online look at photos and price, then hope. The seller usually knows far more than the listing says. The only way to close that gap is to ask, and to ask specific questions that are hard to dodge with a vague, friendly reply. Here are the ones I send before any money moves.
Ask for numbers, not adjectives
"Keeps great time" means nothing. Every seller says it. What you want is a reading from a timegrapher, a small device most watchmakers and many hobbyists own, that listens to the movement and reports three figures. A phone app can give a rough version, but a proper machine is better.
The first figure is rate, in seconds gained or lost per day. For an ordinary mechanical watch, anything within about plus or minus 15 seconds is normal; a certified chronometer should sit between minus 4 and plus 6. The second is amplitude, measured in degrees, which tells you how strongly the balance wheel swings. On a fully wound watch lying dial up, a healthy figure is usually somewhere around 270 to 310 degrees. Once it drops toward 220 or lower, the oils have likely dried and a service is close. The third is beat error, in milliseconds, which should ideally be under 1.0.
Ask for a photo of the timegrapher screen, taken with the watch still in the frame. A seller who has nothing to hide will often send it within a day. A seller who replies "it runs perfectly, no need" has told you something too.
The service history is where the money hides
A full service on a mechanical watch is not cheap. For a simple three hand automatic at an independent watchmaker, expect a few hundred dollars. For a chronograph, or for a brand that insists on its own service centre, the bill can run past a thousand. Rolex suggests roughly every ten years; Omega has generally pointed owners to somewhere between five and eight.
So my questions here are blunt. When was it last serviced, and by whom? Is there a receipt or a service card, and can I see a photo of it? Were any parts replaced, and if so, which ones? Three short questions, and the answers can move a fair price by several hundred dollars.
Replaced parts are not automatically bad. A worn mainspring should be replaced. But brands sometimes swap original hands, dials or bezels for new ones during a factory service, and on certain vintage models collectors pay a real premium for the original parts. If the seller says "dial was replaced at service", the price should reflect it. My piece on what affects resale value in a used watch goes into which parts matter most.
If there is no service record at all, I assume the watch needs one and subtract that cost from what I am willing to pay. In my experience this single adjustment is where most "bargains" stop being bargains.
Photos the seller probably did not take
Good listing photos are chosen to flatter. The pictures you need are the ones nobody puts up front. I ask for these specifically:
- The caseback, straight on, in sharp focus, so engravings and any serial number are readable.
- The case side between the lugs at six o'clock, where some brands placed serial numbers for decades. Older Rolex models are the classic example.
- The clasp from inside, where stretch and scratches tell you how hard the bracelet has been worn.
- A side profile of the case, which shows whether the edges are still crisp or have been rounded by heavy polishing.
- A short video of the watch running, with the crown pulled to set the time and pushed back in, so you can see the hands move and the crown work.
Polishing is the one most buyers miss. Each time a case goes on a buffing wheel, a little steel comes off. Sharp bevels on the lugs turn soft, and once they are gone, they are gone. A watch that looks shiny and "like new" in the listing is sometimes a watch that has been polished three times, and that hurts value on anything collectible.
Ask the seller to write your name or the date on a scrap of paper and include it in one photo. This is the simplest way I know to confirm the person actually has the watch in hand, rather than lifting pictures from an old listing.
Box and papers, and the questions behind them
"Full set" means the box, the warranty card or certificate, and usually the manuals and any spare links. On a modern Rolex, Omega or Tudor, a full set can add something like 10 to 20 percent to resale price compared with the watch alone. On a Seiko or Hamilton, it matters far less.
What I actually want to know is whether the serial number on the papers matches the serial on the watch. Ask the seller to confirm both and photograph them together. Papers from a different watch do turn up, and occasionally they are not a mistake.
Also ask about extra links. A bracelet sized down for a small wrist with the spare links lost can make the watch unwearable for someone with a 19 centimetre wrist, and original replacement links can cost more than you would guess.
Reading the replies
How a seller answers often matters as much as what they say. Prompt, specific replies with photos are a good sign. Defensive replies, sudden urgency ("another buyer is interested, I need an answer tonight") or a request to move payment off the platform are reasons to walk away. I have walked from at least four watches I liked for exactly that reason, and I do not regret any of them.
Before you start messaging, it helps to have a ceiling price fixed in your head, which is the core of buying a first good watch without overspending.
Save the list before you browse
This week, copy the questions above into a note on your phone: timegrapher photo with rate, amplitude and beat error; last service date and receipt; replaced parts; caseback, lug, clasp and profile photos; a dated paper in shot; and matching serial numbers on the papers. The next time a listing tempts you, paste the whole list into a message before you even ask the price. Sellers who answer all of it are the ones worth buying from. More guides on choosing well are in the buying section.
More in Buying a Watch
Buying a Watch
How to Spot a Fake Watch Before You Hand Over Cash
A friend sent me eleven photographs of a steel diver he had agreed to buy for 4,100 in cash, meeting in a supermarket car park...
Buying a Watch
How to Buy a Watch at Auction Without Overpaying
The hammer falls at 3,200 and for about four seconds you think you have just bought a watch for 3,200.
Buying a Watch
Duty Free Watch Buying and Whether It Really Saves Money
You have two hours before boarding, the airport watch boutique has the model you have been eyeing for months, and the sign says...