Shibiao Watches logo Shibiao WatchesUnderstanding watches, plainly
Watch Care

Do You Need a Watch Winder for an Automatic Watch

I bought a two slot winder before I owned two automatics worth winding. It cost 142 pounds in a January sale, ran on a quiet Japanese motor, and spent roughly five months rotating an empty cuff while the one automatic I actually wore...

A single slot watch winder on a shelf holding an automatic watch beside its empty second cradle

I bought a two slot winder before I owned two automatics worth winding. It cost 142 pounds in a January sale, ran on a quiet Japanese motor, and spent roughly five months rotating an empty cuff while the one automatic I actually wore stayed on my wrist. That is the honest shape of a lot of winder purchases. The box arrives, it looks serious on a shelf, and then it spends its life keeping a watch wound that nobody is about to pick up.

Whether winders work is not really the question. They do exactly what the box claims: they rotate a case so the rotor swings and the mainspring holds tension. The question is whether that solves a problem you have. For one automatic with a 40 hour reserve that you wear five days a week, it does not. For a perpetual calendar you strap on twice a month, it can save you twenty minutes of corrector pushing every single time. Those two situations get handed the same advice online, which is how people end up with a 300 pound accessory next to a watch that still needs setting.

What a winder is actually replacing

An automatic winds itself from wrist motion. A weighted rotor turns on a pivot, a reverser gear converts both directions of swing into one direction of winding, and the mainspring builds tension. Left still, the watch runs down over its power reserve: usually 38 to 45 hours on older movements, 70 to 80 on newer ones such as the Powermatic 80 or the Seiko 6R35. A winder stands in for your arm. Nothing else.

So the comparison is not winder against neglect. It is winder against the fifteen seconds it takes to wind the crown and set the time. On a watch with hours, minutes, seconds and a date, that job is trivial. Unscrew or pull the crown, turn it thirty times, set the time, push it home. The date wants one nudge if the watch sat more than a day. No motor is required for that.

Where the calculation changes is quantity. Six automatics in a drawer, each needing winding and setting before it goes on, is a different chore from one. Even then, most collectors I know rotate three or four watches and leave the rest stopped on purpose, which also makes them easier to store properly. If you are at that stage, the advice in our guide to storing a watch collection safely at home matters more than any motor.

Where the usual argument falls apart

The claim you meet most often is that keeping a watch running stops the lubricants congealing and keeps the movement healthy. I have been told this across a counter and read it on a dozen forums. It does not survive contact with how watch oils actually fail.

Synthetic watch oils, the Moebius 9010 family and the heavier greases used on the barrel and keyless works, degrade through oxidation and migration. They creep away from where they were applied and they thicken as they age, and both happen on a shelf or on a wrist. What a running movement adds is cycles. An escapement ticking continuously is an escapement wearing continuously: 28,800 beats an hour, every hour, nine million a week. Watchmakers quote service intervals in running time for exactly that reason. A watch that lived on a winder for eight years has eight years of wear on its pivots. A watch worn at weekends has closer to two.

There is a kernel of truth hiding in the argument. A watch stored untouched for fifteen years can gum up so completely that the mainspring cannot shift the train at all, and freeing it means a full strip and clean. But that is a decade and a half of neglect, not eight months in a drawer, and a winder is an odd remedy for it. The figures in our piece on how often to service a mechanical watch do not improve because a box was spinning in the spare room.

The cases where a winder earns its shelf space

Calendar complications are the real reason winders exist. A perpetual calendar carries day, date, month, moon phase and leap year, and on most references the only safe way to set it is a careful sequence through small correctors, in order, with the manual open. Rush it or run it backwards past a forbidden window and you are paying a watchmaker to undo the damage. Twenty minutes of that twice a month is genuinely miserable, and keeping the watch alive on a winder is the sane answer.

Annual calendars and complete calendars sit a step below: still fiddly, still a fair case. A GMT, a day date, a chronograph or a plain three hander does not qualify. Those take seconds to set and the winder is buying you nothing but the hum.

The second honest case is physical. Readers write to me about arthritis, grip strength after a stroke, and crowns so small that thirty turns leaves a thumb sore for an hour. If winding hurts, a winder is an accessibility tool rather than a toy, and I would not talk anyone out of it. A friend in Leeds with rheumatoid arthritis keeps her late father's Oyster Perpetual turning for precisely this reason, and she has never once asked me what the resale value of the box is.

Reading the spec sheet without getting sold to

Two numbers decide whether a winder suits a watch: turns per day and direction. Turns per day, usually written TPD, is how many full rotations the cradle makes in 24 hours. Too few and the watch stops anyway. Direction matters because some rotors only wind one way, so a clockwise only setting will fail a movement that needs the other direction. Most quoted figures come from the movement maker, and the common ones look like this.

MovementTurns per dayDirection
ETA 2824-2650Both
Sellita SW200-1650Both
Rolex 3135 and 3235650 to 800Both
Seiko 4R36 and NH35800Clockwise
Miyota 9015650Both
Omega 8800800Both

A decent winder does not spin all day to hit those numbers. It turns for a few minutes, rests, and repeats, which is why a unit set to 650 TPD might run six short cycles an hour. Continuous rotation at that rate would overwind nothing, since the slipping clutch protects the mainspring, but it wears the motor and makes noise you will grow to hate. Anything above about 35 decibels in a bedroom is a mistake I have made twice.

Two other details separate a 60 pound unit from a 200 pound one. The first is the motor and its shielding: cheap unshielded motors sitting an inch from a case back can leave a watch running fast, and a watch that suddenly gains eight seconds a day after a week on a winder is usually a magnetised watch rather than a broken one. The second is power. Battery driven winders at 650 TPD chew through four AA cells in three to five weeks, so budget for a mains adapter or expect a drawer full of dead batteries.

If you still want one, here is the modest version of the advice: buy a single slot unit from a maker that publishes TPD and direction settings, spend 80 to 150, put it somewhere you cannot hear it, and set it to the lowest TPD that keeps the watch running. That last step takes a week of checking and saves years of motor hours. If the watch keeps time happily at 650, there is no prize for 1,000.

FAQ

Does leaving an automatic on a winder damage it?

Not suddenly, and not through overwinding, because the clutch slips once the mainspring is full. What it does is add running hours, and running hours are what service intervals are measured in. A watch kept turning permanently will reach its next service sooner than the same watch worn three days a week.

How many turns per day does my watch need?

Look up the movement rather than the brand, since one brand uses several calibres. Most Swiss movements sit at 650 both directions and most Seiko calibres at 800 clockwise. If you cannot find a figure, start at 650 both directions and raise it only if the watch stops overnight.

Is a cheap winder safe to use?

Sometimes, and the risk is magnetism rather than mechanical harm. Run a compass needle near the cradle with the power on. If it twitches, keep the watch somewhere else. I have seen two 50 pound units fail that test and one pass it.

Should I wind a new automatic by hand first?

Yes, around thirty turns of the crown before you put it on, unless the movement has no hand winding at all. Starting from a full mainspring gives you accurate timekeeping from the first hour instead of the unreliable readings you get from a half wound watch. More on the reasoning sits in our watch care section.

BS
Bennett Shaw

Bennett writes about choosing and wearing watches for people new to them, focused on value and good sense over hype.

More posts by Bennett

More in Watch Care

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto